Category: News This Week

  • FDA to appeal against graphic warning ruling

    FDA to appeal against graphic warning ruling

    The US government is appealing against a federal judge’s ruling that has overturned a requirement for graphic warning labels to be included on cigarette packs, according to a Bloomberg News story.

    The Food and Drug Administration has filed a notice of appeal in the US District Court in Washington seeking to overturn Judge Richard Leon’s February 29 decision that the government’s requirement violates the tobacco companies’ rights to free speech.

    The US Court of Appeals in Washington is already scheduled to hear arguments on April 10 on the government’s challenge to a ruling Leon issued in November that cancelled a September 22 deadline for tobacco companies to begin including the graphic images.

    It is unclear whether the three-judge panel will consider the latest appeal on April 10.

    The graphic images – nine in all – would have had to have taken up the top halves of the front and back of all cigarette packages and the top fifth of all advertising.

    However, the requirement was challenged by R.J. Reynolds Tobacco, Lorillard, the Liggett Group, Commonwealth Brands, and Santa Fe Natural Tobacco Co Inc on the grounds that it would force them to engage in anti-smoking advocacy against their own legal products.

    In a statement posted on its website, Reynolds said that Judge Leon had agreed with the tobacco companies that the proposed warnings violated the First Amendment by forcing manufacturers to distribute an anti-smoking policy message.

    The court cited data included in the FDA’s regulation that showed the graphic warnings would have little to no effect in reducing tobacco use. In particular, the FDA’s analysis of the regulation estimated that the warnings would likely cause no statistically significant change in US smoking rates.

    The court noted also that the chief expert report relied on by the FDA conceded that the goal of such graphic warnings ‘is not to promote informed choice but rather to discourage consumption of tobacco products’.

  • India preparing something to chew on

    India preparing something to chew on

    The Indian Health Ministry seems set to codify a ban on gutkha, pan masala and other chewable forms of tobacco, according to a story in the latest issue of the BBM Bommidala Group newsletter.

    For some time, the situation regarding these products has been confusing with the sale of chewable forms of tobacco seemingly illegal but not specifically banned.

    Now, the ministry seems to be set on acting on the basis of a Supreme Court of India observation that these products are classified as food items, to which the addition of tobacco is illegal.

    What the outcome will be is difficult to say, but the banning of products widely used and generally thought to be addictive will be an interesting social experiment.

    It has to be assumed that illicit sales will increase and that some consumers of these products will turn to smoking.

    Neither of these would seem to constitute a positive health outcome.

  • Siemens motors united under Simotics name

    The Siemens Drive Technologies Division has combined all of its electric motors under one brand name, Simotics, a move designed to integrate its portfolio and improve clarity for customers.

    The range of motors encompasses low-voltage induction motors, motors for motion control applications, DC motors, and high-voltage motors.

    “Siemens motors represent reliability, energy efficiency, dynamic response, and precision born out of more than 125 years of experience in electric motor construction,” said Doug Keith, president of the division.

    “Having our entire portfolio under one brand name helps to position Siemens as a single source for integrated drive train solutions, thus saving costs for the customer.”

  • DC

    Currently waiting at Washington Dulles for the last leg of my return trip to Raleigh-Durham. The flight from Addis Ababa arrived early and I could probably have caught an earlier onward flight to RDU—but United Airlines now charges $75 for traveling standby, so as a good Dutchman I’ll keep the cash in my pocket and wait for the scheduled flight.

    Everything is considered “extra” if you fly economy in the U.S. these days—peanuts, checked luggage, earphones. It won’t be long until they start charging for the life vests as well. The airlines’ marketing people will surely find a way to sell the floatation devices as added comfort “in the unlikely event of an emergency.”

    The flight from Addis made (for me) an unexpected stop in Rome, which explains the whopping 17-hour-and-25-minute flying time to Washington. It’s interesting to see old colonial ties between countries persisting in the routing of flights. When I traveled to Rwanda last year, the connection was through Brussels.

    The dearth of flights between Harare and London, on the other hand, reflects the frosty relationship between Zimbabwe and its former colonial master. Come to think of it, there aren’t too many airlines calling on the Harare’s gleaming airport, which opened only a few years ago. Aside from two seemingly mothballed Air Zimbabwe aircraft, our Ethiopian Airlines plane was the only one on the tarmac yesterday.

    I have filled several notebooks on this trip, and I am still not sure if I have a good grasp on the Zimbabwean situation. Has land reform succeeded or has not? Hopefully I can put the pieces together as I review my notes this week.

    In the meantime, I will have to unlearn some of the driving habits I acquired during my stay in Zimbabwe, especially around intersections.

    The worst traffic situations didn’t involve traffic lights that were disabled, but those that worked partially—with only the green bulb functioning, for example. On several occasions, the only clues about the colors of the lights came from the horn blowing and hand gestures from fellow motorists.

  • VPN fun

    As tobacco veterans know, travel is hurry up and wait. During the down times you need something to entertain yourself. Technology makes that easier.

    I have downloaded to my smart phone an application that allows me to access my computer at work. That enhances productivity, but it can also be used to play tricks on your co-workers.

    For example, Google’s translation service (www.translate.google.com) has a function that lets your PC articulate the translated sentence. That’s handy if you’re not sure to how to pronounce words in a foreign language, but you can also use it to make your computer say bad words.

    Last night, I spent part of my evening at York Lodge instructing my computer in Raleigh, N.C., to utter inappropriate statements.

    It kept me entertained for a good hour, trying to picture my startled co-workers trying to figure out where the bad language was coming from.

    Unfortunately, I haven’t gotten a reaction yet, which can mean two things: Either my speakers were turned off (I cannot activate those remotely), or the company president happened to be standing nearby just as I was typing vulgarities. In the latter case, this might be my last post as editor of Tobacco Reporter.

  • Bursting at the seams

    Hey, big spender

    To appreciate the shift that has taken place in the Zimbabwean tobacco industry over the past decade, consider these figures: In 2000, approximately 4,000 growers sold 240 million kg. This year, the Zimbabwe Tobacco Association is expecting sales of about 160 million kg—produced by a whopping 60,000 farmers.

    Designed for commercial production, the country’s marketing infrastructure is bursting at the seams. Whereas in the past a single farmer might deliver 100 bales, now hundreds of farmers will queue up to deliver three or five bales each.

    And the farmers don’t come by themselves. Often, they are accompanied not only by family members but also by creditors who hope to collect before the farmer spends his paycheck.

    In May, the line of tobacco growers and their entourage at the Tobacco Sales Floors stretched for five kilometers, according to a leaf merchants whose offices overlook the auction.

    The presence of so many people with fresh cash in their pockets, in turn, has attracted others hoping to sell to them their goods and services. Makeshift marketplaces have sprung up around all three tobacco auctions in Harare, offering everything from tractors to telephone cards.

    Some are even more ambitious. I had dinner last night with Temba Mliswa—an interesting character worth Googling—who wants to open a fourth tobacco auction near the Boka floor. He’s already filed an application with the Tobacco Marketing and Industry Board. While not everybody in the trade believes expanding capacity is the way to go—some prefer optimizing operations at the existing facilities—Mliswa’s plans underscore the extent of the changes taking place in Zimbabwe.

  • Going, going, gone

    Auctioning of leaf at the Tobacco Sales Floors in Harare this morning

  • Peaceful rise

    Zhang Qinggang and an unidentified visitor. The characters in the background mean "harmony," I think.

    I was surprised to run into Patrick Rose at Northern Tobacco in Harare. I had met Patrick several years ago when he was looking after BAT’s leaf growing operations in Uganda, and he seemed to enjoy being back in his home country.

    Later that morning, I caught up with Zhang Qinggang, managing director of Tianze Tobacco, a subsidiary of the China National Tobacco Corp. The Chinese have become a significant player in Zimbabwe lately, at times purchasing up to 40 percent of the crop.

    Like other manufacturers, CNTC has become concerned about security of supply in recent years. In April 2005, it established Tianze. Today the company contracts with 170 farmers (both small-scale and commercial) and also purchases at auction.

    Echoing concerns in some parts of the world about China’s rise as an economic superpower, some in Zimbabwe have expressed discomfort with the growing Chinese role in the leaf tobacco sector.

    Zhang was keen to stress that Tianze was not “taking over” Zimbabwe’s tobacco business. “We want to support the industry, play by the rules and contribute to healthy market conditions,” he said, adding that up to 98 percent of the company’s employees were local.

  • Whirlwind

    Dr. Andrew Matibiri, the late Roger Boka and his daughter, Rudo Boka

    I visited the Tobacco Sales Floors this morning, interviewed Greg McDonald at Inter-Continental Leaf and caught up with Dr. Andrew Matibiri at the Tobacco Industry and Marketing Board, who introduced me to Rudo Boka.

    Rudo is the daughter of the late Roger Boka, a controversial black-empowerment entrepreneur who in the 1990s built what was supposed to become the world’s largest tobacco auction facility in Harare. Eager to service the tens of thousands of “new” small-scale growers, the Boka family has recently taken control of the facility again and is now working feverishly to put into place the infrastructure required to cope with such numbers.

    I then had lunch with Adam Molai, chief executive of Savannah Tobacco Co. Savannah has grown considerably since I last visited the company and is now housed in the former Burley sales floor.

    In the late afternoon, I visited Dr. Dahlia Garwe, assistant general manager of the famous Kutsaga tobacco research station. We spoke about the rise of small-scale farming at the expense of commercial growing and how Kutsaga had adjusted its programs in response to the new realities.

    My head is now spinning with new impressions and insights. But rather than trying to make sense of them this evening, I think I’ll have a beer with my eclectic lodge mates instead.

    Fresh deliveries