Massachusetts’ highest court rejected an effort by Philip Morris USA to impose stricter standards on punitive damages, allowing a previously reduced $56 million verdict to stand. The company had sought additional legal limits to curb large punitive awards, but the court declined to adopt new rules.
The case stems from a lawsuit in which the original $1 billion punitive damages award had already been significantly reduced by a lower court. Philip Morris argued for further reductions and broader changes to how such damages are assessed, but the justices upheld the existing framework.