Category: Global Regulation

  • Bidi Opens Latest Appeal Against FDA

    Bidi Opens Latest Appeal Against FDA

    Yesterday (April 2), Bidi Vapor LLC urged the Eleventh Circuit to reverse a U.S. Food and Drug Administration decision denying its application to market a disposable e-cigarette, saying the agency acted unlawfully. In oral arguments in Miami, attorney Eric Gotting told an appellate panel that the FDA’s decision was “arbitrary and capricious and unlawful,” and that the agency admitted adult smokers would likely switch to Bidi’s safer product—a disposable e-cigarette prefilled with tobacco-flavored e-liquid—but still denied the application.

    In January 2024, the FDA issued a marketing denial order (MDO) for the tobacco-flavored Bidi Stick-Classic disposable vape. The decision came while the agency was continuing a court-ordered second review of marketing applications for flavored Bidi Vapor products. The FDA said Bidi’s premarket tobacco application “did not demonstrate an overall net benefit to people who use tobacco products and lacked sufficient evidence to address health risks.”

    Bidi believes the FDA violated the Administrative Procedure Act and hopes to build on its record of successfully contesting adverse FDA decisions. In August 2022, the 11th Circuit set aside the original MDOs issued for its 10 non-tobacco-flavored products. That ruling put the 10 PMTAs back into scientific review and allowed those flavors to remain available for sale pursuant to the FDA’s compliance policy for deemed tobacco products.

  • Maldives Proposing Generational Ban on Tobacco

    Maldives Proposing Generational Ban on Tobacco

    During a podcast hosted by his office, Maldives President Dr. Mohamed Muizzu said that he is considering three proposals for a “generation ban” on tobacco, aiming to prevent younger generations from smoking. The proposals differed only in date, when people would be forever banned from smoking if born after January 1 in either 2000, 2004, or 2007.

    Explaining the rationale behind these options, President Muizzu stated that focusing on the 18 to 25 age group and below would make it easier to prevent addiction before it becomes deep-seated. He also highlighted the importance of consulting medical professionals and other stakeholders in formulating the policy and said that Health Minister Abdulla Nazim Ibrahim has been tasked with drafting a Cabinet paper on the proposed ban.

  • Belgium Tobacco Display Ban Goes into Effect

    Belgium Tobacco Display Ban Goes into Effect

    Belgium’s new laws to limit the visibility of cigarettes and other nicotine products, with the hope of curbing impulse purchases, went into effect yesterday (April 1). Cigarettes and other tobacco products can no longer be displayed in shops and stores larger than 400 square meters are banned from selling such products altogether. This is the second phase of a program that included the ban of disposable e-cigarettes beginning Jan. 1.

    “Our ambition is to have a smoke-free generation by 2040,” said Belgian Health Minister Frank Vandenbroucke. “From now on, it is illegal to have cigarettes or vapes on display, that is visible, in a store. It is not a prohibition on buying this stuff. You can buy it, but you have to ask the vendor.”

    No specific guidance or material on how to handle tobacco products was provided to retailers. Each shop has had to find its own solution to the display ban, from handmade plastic curtains to sophisticated shelves that automatically light up when opened.

    “It is annoying because the government hasn’t given us any supply,” said news and tobacco shop owner Jenny Van Vaerenbergh. “They should have provided the necessary equipment.”

  • Sources: Big Changes for Hong Kong Tobacco Laws in 2026  

    Sources: Big Changes for Hong Kong Tobacco Laws in 2026  

    Last year, Hong Kong’s Special Administrative Region government proposed 10 tobacco control measures that prompted backlash from businesses and smokers alike. Now, sources say the Health Bureau plans to submit an amendment bill to the Legislative Council by the end of this month based on those measures, which would include items such as increased penalties for illegal tobacco sales, a ban on flavored cigarettes, and expanded smoke-free areas.

    The sources said the regulations would be implemented in 2026, typically in two phases.

    E-cigarettes would be banned in public spaces starting as early as the second quarter of next year, with potential extensions to private areas and other devices depending on favorable outcomes. The ban on flavored cigarettes would begin with non-menthol flavors first, and then menthol later, with no specific timeline set.

    The new proposal would also focus on combating illegal tobacco, with a trial starting mid-year to add identification labels on duty-paid cigarettes. Authorities would also increase penalties for smuggling; the maximum fine for buying, selling, or possessing illegal cigarettes will rise from HK$1 million ($130,000) and two years in prison to HK$2 million ($260,000) and seven years in prison. Travelers bringing more than 19 packs of duty-free cigarettes to Hong Kong would see fines increased from HK$5,000 ($650) to over HK$8,000 ($1,040).

  • Supreme Court Favors FDA in Flavor Battle

    Supreme Court Favors FDA in Flavor Battle

    Today (April 2), the Supreme Court unanimously overturned a lower court’s decision that the U.S. Food and Drug Administration incorrectly blocked flavored nicotine e-liquids, rejecting e-cigarette makers that were challenging regulatory hurdles on tobacco products.

    E-liquid companies Triton Distribution and Vapetasia LLC claimed the FDA unlawfully denied the marketing authorization for flavored vape products and disputed that the products appealed to children, arguing that the government was harming nicotine-addicted adults by keeping a cigarette alternative off the market.

    The vape companies argued the FDA failed to review the company’s own scientific evidence, which demonstrates its flavored products were crucial to getting smokers to switch from combustible cigarettes to e-cigarettes. The Fifth Circuit Court agreed with the e-cigarette maker, ruling that “the agency’s rejection was arbitrary and capricious because the FDA relied on conflicting evidence requirements.” The court also faulted the FDA for dismissing “out-of-hand companies’ strategies to keep their products away from minors.” The agency said such efforts haven’t proven to be effective.

    Public health groups had already sued the FDA for not moving fast enough to review the products after the agency, in 2016, finalized rules for regulating them under the 2009 Family Smoking Prevention and Tobacco Control Act. Under the Act, vape companies were forced to submit applications to the FDA in order to bring new vape flavors to market, and the FDA was to assess the public health effects of those products. A rift, however, emerged over the agency’s criteria for approving or denying those applications, which culminated in the Fifth Circuit.

    The fight was brought to the Supreme Court in November with the FDA contending it correctly applied the Tobacco Control Act, saying it considered both the “likelihood that existing users of tobacco products will stop using such products” and the “likelihood that those who do not use tobacco products will start using such products.”

    Oral arguments in front of the Supreme Court centered on whether the FDA standards are a policy position or a substantive rule imposed without notice and comment. The Biden administration argued the standards fell into the policy bucket, pushing the court to give the agency deference to interpret its role under the Tobacco Control Act. 

    Under the Biden administration, the FDA rejected more than a million flavored products, saying companies failed to show that flavored vapes will do more to benefit public health by helping smokers quit tobacco products than the harm they cause by appealing to young people.

    Vaping companies hope they’ll find a friendlier regulatory environment under the Trump administration, as the President previously promised to “save” flavored vaping.

  • Australia’s New Packaging Warnings Take Effect

    Australia’s New Packaging Warnings Take Effect

    Beginning today (April 1), Australia’s new cigarette packaging laws have gone into effect, including that each individual cigarette has a health warning printed on it. Warning phrases include “causes 16 cancers,” “damages your lungs,” and “poisons in every puff.” Canada is the only other country in the world to have such requirements.

    The new laws that went into effect also introduced 10 new graphic health warnings that will be printed on tobacco packaging as well as 10 new inserts that will be placed inside packaging, providing information on the benefits of quitting smoking.

    Sarah Durkin from the Cancer Council said that the graphic health warnings on tobacco packaging have proven effective in educating Australians about the harms of smoking but that the effectiveness of the warnings has decreased over time. 

    “We also have new scientific information that extends our knowledge of the health effects of tobacco use,” she said. “The new graphic health warnings feature some of these harms of smoking that people may not be aware of, such as diabetes, erectile dysfunction, cervical cancer, DNA damage, and the impact of second-hand smoke on children’s lung capacity.”

  • Brian King, Dozens of Staffers Out at CTP

    Brian King, Dozens of Staffers Out at CTP

    The Associated Press is reporting that Brian King, the Food and Drug Administration’s chief tobacco regulator, was removed from his post this morning (April 1) amid sweeping cuts at the agency and across the federal health workforce. According to sources familiar with the situation, King sent an email to staff saying, “It is with a heavy heart and profound disappointment that I share I have been placed on administrative leave.”

    King was removed from his position and offered reassignment to the Indian Health Service, according to a person familiar with the matter who did not have permission to discuss the matter publicly and spoke on the condition of anonymity. Dozens of staffers in the FDA’s Center for Tobacco Products (CTP) also received notices of dismissal Tuesday morning, including the entire office responsible for enforcing tobacco regulations.

    In recent years, the CTP has been besieged by criticism from all sides, including politicians, anti-smoking advocates, and tobacco and vaping companies. Under King, the FDA rejected applications for millions of flavored e-cigarettes, citing insufficient data that the products would help adult smokers while not becoming popular with underage kids. Those rejections have resulted in multiple lawsuits against FDA from vape makers.

    “King, who joined the agency in 2022, has been vigorously criticized by vaping lobbyists for ordering thousands of companies to remove their fruit and candy-flavored e-cigarettes from the market,” the AP wrote. “During his time at FDA, teen vaping has fallen to a 10-year low.”

    The latest changes mean that nearly all of FDA’s top leaders overseeing drugs, food, vaccines, medical devices, and now tobacco products have resigned or retired in recent months. This comes after Robert F. Kennedy Jr.’s moves to fire 3,500 FDA staffers and push ahead with plans to scrutinize ultra-processed foods, childhood vaccines, antidepressants, and other long-established products.

  • Leaked EU Document Calls for “Substantial” Taxes on Nicotine Pouches

    Leaked EU Document Calls for “Substantial” Taxes on Nicotine Pouches

    According to The Vaping Post, a confidential European Commission (EC) document, leaked by Snusjournalen, has revealed a contentious plan to impose a substantial EU-wide tax increase on nicotine pouches (NPs). Spearheaded by the Directorate-General for Taxation and Customs Union (DG TAXUD), the proposed measure could trigger widespread economic, political, and criminal repercussions across the Union.

    Europe already finds itself in a tenuous economic situation, dealing with economic instability that includes inflation and escalating trade tensions with the United States. Worse on the nicotine front, a recent Europol report shared by Euroreporter, “The Changing DNA of Serious and Organised Crime,” highlights the direct link between excessive taxation and the rise of black markets—specifically citing tobacco and nicotine products. The report warns that strict tax policies create opportunities for criminal networks to expand operations, smuggle products across borders, and launder illicit funds. Experts fear that a steep price increase on NPs could drive a surge in illicit sales, with products being illegally imported from non-EU nations like China.

    Although the European Commission has yet to confirm the directive publicly, the leak has already sparked significant concerns among key stakeholders, including law enforcement, investors, and consumer advocacy groups. Given Europol’s warnings on illicit trade and the broader political and economic climate, this proposed tax increase is shaping up to be one of the most contentious regulatory battles in the coming months.

    “In light of these developments, the proposed tax hike on NPs adds yet another layer of uncertainty to an already volatile regulatory and economic landscape,” wrote The Vaping Post. “More importantly, with the vaping industry currently facing such a critical juncture, which could result in less availability of vaping products to smokers using them to quit, a harsh tax set on snus would be currently all the more detrimental to public health.”

  • Tennessee Bill Would Outlaw Most Vape Products

    Tennessee Bill Would Outlaw Most Vape Products

    A bill in Tennessee that would impose a state tax of up to 10% on vape products – a higher rate than tobacco – and effectively ban the sale of many vape products in the state by requiring application for FDA approval before products are sold is headed for a final Senate vote this week. Senate Bill 763 passed the Senate Finance Committee in a 9-2 vote, and a counterpart House panel with bipartisan support.

    Bill sponsor Ken Yager said the bill is aimed at stopping “the influx of Chinese vape products that are addicting our children and wreaking havoc on our schools” ― not an attack on Tennessee’s vape industry. However, critics say it is a “legislative weapon for big tobacco to crush competition.”

    “I don’t take my orders from big tobacco,” Yager told reporters.

    If signed into law, the bill would ban the sale of vapor products including hundreds of disposable and flavored products in Tennessee that are not approved or in the process of being approved by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration. Currently, just 34 vapor products have been approved by the FDA, and all are tied to big tobacco companies. Most vape products sold in the U.S. are imported from China. If passed, the bill would fine vape retailers $500 to $1,500 per product illegally sold.

    According to The Tennessean, Tennessee is one of about 20 states that does not currently levy a tax on vape products. If passed, the bill would impose a 10% tax on open system vape products and a 7% tax on closed system vape products. Tennessee taxes tobacco products at 6.6%. Yager told reporters his proposed tax on vape products “is really no different from the tax on other nicotine products.”

  • CAPHRA Urges COP11 Attendees to Shift View on Harm Reduction 

    CAPHRA Urges COP11 Attendees to Shift View on Harm Reduction 

    The Coalition of Asia Pacific Tobacco Harm Reduction Advocates (CAPHRA) today (March 31) urged global tobacco control policymakers to abandon outdated prohibitionist approaches and embrace harm reduction strategies grounded in science.  

    Ahead of the Framework Convention on Tobacco Control’s (FCTC) COP11 meeting later this year, CAPHRA emphasized that meaningful progress requires inclusion, transparency, and a commitment to evidence-based policymaking. 

    Despite decades of tobacco control efforts, global smoking rates have stagnated at 1.1 billion smokers since 2000. CAPHRA attributes this failure to the FCTC’s refusal to engage with harm reduction strategies or include consumer organizations in its decision-making processes. 

    “The FCTC’s ‘quit or die’ approach has failed. It’s time for a mindset shift that prioritizes science over ideology and inclusion over exclusion,” Nancy Loucas, CAPHRA Executive Coordinator, said. “Consumer organizations like CAPHRA represent millions who have successfully transitioned to safer alternatives—our lived experiences must inform policy. 

    “COP11 presents an opportunity for the WHO FCTC to finally grant observer status to consumer advocacy groups. Without the voices of those directly impacted by tobacco harm reduction strategies, policymaking remains disconnected from reality. The secrecy surrounding COP meetings undermines trust and progress. Hosting open consultations with civil society during proceedings would ensure accountability and bring much-needed balance to global tobacco control discussions.”